ntp.conf changes for NTS
Hal Murray
hmurray at megapathdsl.net
Fri Feb 1 00:33:23 UTC 2019
Eric said:
> If there's another revision in process, I want to object to the binary
> request format. Raises endianness issues for no good reason. Better to use
> something like Motorola S-records for this.
I don't see how hex encoding helps anything. You still have the problem of
are integers sent big-endian or little-endian.
I was expecting you to suggest JSON. A lot of IETF work uses ASN1.
I'm not convinced your switch-to-text is appropriate for this problem. The
key idea is that the basic NTP packet is small and fixed format. Converting
to text either adds another dependency with a complicated API because it's
designed to handle complicated cases or we have to maintain another module to
do the marshalling/unmarshalling.
I'm probably biased. I've been working with byte swapping for ages.
Adding extensions (which are necessary for NTS) complicates things. I'm hoping that you would come up with a clean structure.
--
These are my opinions. I hate spam.
More information about the devel
mailing list